Marguerite Barrett

Contributing Writer

So, how did I do? Let’s just say Rory doesn’t have anything to worry about from me anytime soon…

Seriously, though, while I identified two of the wines correctly, one was a complete fluke. The other, though, wasn’t, and I was particularly proud of myself for recognizing this because it was the McLaughlin Merlot. And no, I wasn’t too proud to say I told you so. As soon as I smelled it, I knew it was a Northeastern wine. I don’t know if it’s the soil or or that despite the tempering influence of the ocean, it’s colder here than along the California coast, but there is a brightness and a “tang” to the Long Island/Northeastern grapes, particularly the reds, that is very noticeable. I was proud of myself for recognizing it – and I’ll definitely be doing some more research to figure out exactly what it is that I’m picking up.

As for the others…

Wine #1 with a total of 6 points Lindemans, 2005 – South Africa

Wine #2 with a total of 4 points, and 3 votes for this being the Ringer Ravenswood 2006 – California

Wine #3 with a total of 24 points and the overwhelming favorite of the evening Tilia 2006 – Mendoza, Argentina

Wine #4 with a total of 4 points McLaughlin Vineyards – Connecticut (Long Island Grapes)

Wine #5 with only 1 point and 1 vote for this being the Ringer Chateau de Castelneau 2005 – Bordeaux, France

Wine #6 with a total of 8 points and 3 votes for this being the Ringer (this was the one I suspected was the Ringer) Yellow Tail Reserve 2006 – Southeastern Australia

Wine #7 with no points was THE RINGER! Palestra – Portugal. The label says only that it’s made from grapes indigenous to Portugal. None of us were impressed, but also none of us thought this was the ringer.

Wine #8 with a total of 7 points and 4 votes for this being the ringer Casa Lapostolle 2006 – Rapel Valley, Chile. I had guessed this, but it was a total fluke – I was down to two wines I hadn’t selected yet, so I flipped a coin.

Wine #9 with a total of 9 points Chateau Ste Michelle – Columbia Valley, Washington

All in all a very successful evening. As we left, we all signed up for next month’s seminar, The Wines of France